
L.A. Mayor Karen Bass framed the removal of 2,000 National Guard troops from Los Angeles on July 15 as a victory for the city. (photo by Edwin Folven)
The city of Beverly Hills announced on July 15 that it is joining the federal lawsuit filed by several Southern California cities and the American Civil Liberties Union which seeks to stop the ongoing federal immigration raids in the Los Angeles area. The lawsuit alleges the raids are unconstitutional because they are based on ethnicity and agents do not provide reasonable suspicion or probable cause.
The Beverly Hills City Council voted to join the motion to intervene filed by Los Angeles, West Hollywood, Santa Monica and several other surrounding municipalities during a closed session meeting on July 15. The legal action – first announced by L.A. on July 8 – followed a month of ongoing ICE raids and the deployment of the National Guard in Los Angeles.
The presence of National Guard troops has been the subject of intense criticism from leaders across Los Angeles and California, including L.A. Mayor Karen Bass and Gov. Gavin Newsom, who argued that the deployment was an unconstitutional show of force meant to intimidate. A militarized sweep of MacArthur Park by immigration agents in armored vehicles and on horseback on July 7, which resulted in no arrests, also drew swift condemnation. On July 15, the Pentagon announced that it would withdraw 2,000 National Guard troops from Los Angeles – approximately half of the total National Guard deployed in Los Angeles.
“While the city of Beverly Hills supports enforcement of the law, we stand against any unconstitutional immigration enforcement actions,” Mayor Sharona Nazarian said during the July 15 open session, which followed the closed-door meeting. “We are deeply concerned by allegations that federal agents have targeted individuals based solely on race or ethnicity, conducted raids and arrests without probable cause and used excessive force. As a diverse community including many immigrants, we join the motion to intervene.”
The council voted 4-1 to intervene, with Vice Mayor John Mirisch voting against the measure.
Mirisch said that while he supports the intention of the motion, he voted against it because of the involvement of the ACLU, which he called an “antisemitic institution.” He suggested that the city file its own lawsuit to quell the ICE raids as opposed to joining the ACLU’s litigation.
“The ACLU has politicized civil rights to the exclusion of Jews,” Mirisch said.
Several members of the audience at the public hearing audibly groaned upon hearing Mirisch’s announcement, which prompted a combative response from the vice mayor.
“If you think that in a time of unprecedented antisemitism, that excluding Jews from civil rights is an OK thing, that’s on you,” Mirisch said to the audience members. “Whether you want to be antisemitic or not, that’s on you as well.”
Nazarian attempted to rein in the meeting, which had appeared to spiral into an argument between Mirisch and members of the public.
“You say your statement, and then let’s move on. We have a meeting to conduct,” Nazarian said to Mirisch, before turning to the public. “Please allow Vice Mayor Mirisch to say his statement, and then we’re going to move on.”
While Mirisch’s position caused a stir at the meeting, the city’s motion was celebrated during public comment.
Rebecca Pynoos, chair of the Beverly Hills Architectural and Design Review Commission, read a letter on behalf of the Beverly Hills Community Alliance, a group she described as a coalition of “Republicans, Democrats, independents … longtime residents, parents, business leaders, former school board members, Rotary members, commissioners and community members” from diverse backgrounds in Beverly Hills.
“We are very grateful for your action tonight that shows great bravery,” Pynoos said. “The tactic of sending masked, armed men into our streets to harass and detain innocent people isn’t American. It’s authoritarian. Speaking out on this isn’t political, we feel it is human, and we commend you now for standing up for what’s right.”
On July 11, U.S. District Judge Maame Ewusi-Mensah Frimpong issued a ruling in favor of L.A. and the surrounding cities, barring federal immigration agents from using racial profiling to conduct raids. However, the decision has been appealed by the Trump administration.
Following the announcement that 2,000 National Guard troops would be removed from the city, Bass held a press conference where she characterized the Pentagon’s decision as a victory for Los Angeles.
“This happened because the people of Los Angeles stood united and stood strong. We organized peaceful protests, we came together at rallies, we took the Trump administration to court – all of this led to today’s retreat,” Bass said. “My message today to Angelenos is clear – I will never stop fighting for this city. We will not stop making our voices heard until this ends, not just here in L.A., but throughout our country.”










0 Comment