
Moana (voiced by Auli’i Cravalho) and little sister Simea (voiced by Khaleesi Lambert-Tsuda) are stellar in Disney’s “Moana 2.” (photo courtesy of Disney)
I’ve written film reviews professionally since 2007 (throwback to “30 Days of Night,” my first). I try to provide folks with thoughtful pieces and hopefully a few laughs as I promote films I find worthwhile or warn against those that might be a waste. Occasionally, I break ranks, present a different thesis. “Moana 2” requires such a detour.
Often I agree with other film critics or at least see their point. But on occasion, a film premieres that creates a highbrow groupthink that everyday moviegoers should entirely ignore. That’s the case with “Moana 2,” a film with a 62% from film pedants on Rotten Tomatoes and lackluster reactions presented by review aggregators and social media’s ranks of film influencers.
The San Francisco Chronicle called it “ill-conceived,” while the Guardian considers it devoid of “anything genuinely passionate or heartfelt.” Plenty of others agree. But what if I see in “Moana 2” an entirely enjoyable experience overflowing with passion and heart? Should I give up this whole review gig? I know I’m not alone.
An 87% from RT users, a 7.1/10 from IMDb ones (which is quite good for the site) and an A- from exit polling by CinemaScore. By themselves, each variable can be countered, especially if you know how awful RT users can be. But one variable doesn’t lie: money. After its second week at the box office, the sequel surpassed $600 million worldwide nearing the entire box office gross of its predecessor. It’ll likely end north of $1 billion, the third film to do so this year (joining Disney alum’s “Inside Out 2” and “Deadpool and Wolverine”). I love that for “Moana 2.”
So what is this sequel if not the “remarkably thin piece of storytelling,” according to rogerebert.com?
It’s a sequel with more to do, but it never leaves its focus on Moana for too long. Expect a few throwbacks and a whole lot more lore. Moana (Auli’i Cravalho) is now her people’s Wayfinder in search of others. No success yet. Then a vision sets her on a path that will, of course, require a reunion with that snarky, shapeshifting demigod Maui (Dwayne Johnson).
This particular task will take Moana much farther than last time, so she’ll need a crew, including ship crafter Loto (Rose Matafeo), history buff Moni (Hualālai Chung) and cranky chef Kele (David Fane). It’s clear these three are a relic of “Moana 2’s” previous gestation as a Disney+ series before Disney CEO Bob Iger changed course on this one.
For several naysayers, this is condemnable. Many like the Boston Globe and AV Club even compare the film to Disney’s direct-to-video era. Absolutely not. That’s an exaggeration that reads well but doesn’t even come close.
One of the more infuriating attacks hails from Vulture, again criticizing Moana’s character development before concluding that “‘Moana 2’ isn’t a real movie. It’s an extension of time-tested IP, a savvy play from a media giant that may struggle mightily when it comes to new original material but has always known how to continue capitalizing on its hits.”
Are we really playing this game? It’s all IP. It’s all part of a capitalist storytelling business model. All different topics. The level of cynicism is unwarranted. I wish I could just praise “Moana 2,” discuss the stunning animation, fun humor and the enjoyable world building. I would even spend more time addressing missteps like those side characters (a couple can be entirely removed) and how none of the new songs are bangers like “How Far I’ll Go” and “You’re Welcome,” though they’re still better than most in “Frozen II,” for those who need a barometer. Instead, I’m here to remind folks that film critics can get it wrong – double-down unnecessarily.
Years ago, a frustrated reader wrote in to chastise me for my negative review of “Mamma Mia,” concluding that I needed to “calm down.” I offer that suggestion to other critics. Art is certainly subjective, but to make “Moana 2” the target of this much ire is wild. You’d think it had nothing at all to offer. It ain’t perfect, but it ain’t that bad either. If for no other reason, go see to annoy those critics.

Demigod Maui (voiced by Dwayne Johnson) makes a magical return in “Moana 2.” (photo courtesy of Disney)




0 Comment