
Los Angeles City Councilman Paul Koretz, 5th District, unveiled a damning report on the state of the L.A. Department of Animal Services as well as a package of motions to improve it. (photo courtesy of the 5th District office)
The Los Angeles Department of Animal Services only has enough resources to properly run four of its six shelters for 2022, City Councilman Paul Koretz, 5th District, said.
The Great Recession of 2007 and 2008 and the COVID-19 pandemic compounded decades of mismanagement, resulting in a network of shelters across the city where dogs live in unclean kennels and are walked and exercised infrequently, cats, rabbits and other small animals are kept in subpar conditions, volunteers and paid staff clash, and not enough animals are adopted or fostered, Koretz said.
Aiming to improve these conditions, Koretz on Oct. 7 released a 46-page report on the state of the department along with a corresponding package of 11 motions.
“I have worked hard to focus this report on making recommendations on how the department can take steps forward to better serve Angelenos and the animals in the department’s care. I hope the report leads to a healthy and productive discussion,” wrote Koretz, who chairs the Council’s Personnel, Audits and Animal Welfare Committee.
The report tackles seven broad concerns, each of which is broken down into greater detail: animal care, adoption and foster programs, shelter facilities, the volunteer program, staffing, community relations and “other issues.”
The motions call for more than $3 million to be made available to L.A. Animal Services, and for city and department officials to revamp the department’s hiring practices, overhaul its volunteer program and improve the facilities and treatment of animals.
Koretz’s spokeswoman Ali Simard did not say when City Council would vote on the motions, though she added that it “is important to [the Personnel, Audits and Animal Welfare Committee] to push the motions through [the council] as soon as possible.”
“[The department] is committed to serving our community by providing programs and resources to keep pets and their families together, and ensuring the safety and well-being of animals, both inside our shelters and out in our communities, and the people who love them. … We appreciate the thought and time that went into the report and will review the recommendations brought forth by Councilmember Koretz,” Agnes Sibal, a spokeswoman for L.A. Animal Services said.
She added, “While increasing funding and adding more staff will help address some of the concerns, caring for animals is an ongoing collaborative effort between the city, the community, and our department. As a municipal shelter, there is always an opportunity to do more, including ways to better engage and educate the community about spaying and neutering their pets, licensing their companion animals and providing other available alternatives to surrendering animals so our shelters aren’t the first or only option for pet owners when faced with financial challenges.”
Eileen Smulson and her husband Brad co-founded Operation Blankets of Love, a nonprofit animal welfare organization that provides supplies and pet food to shelters, assists homeless pet owners and teaches humane pet care to children. They agreed that the city’s shelters are suffering from a lack of staff, volunteers and outreach with the community, and they hoped that Koretz’s motions could be a fresh start for the beleaguered organization.
“The idea is this, let’s be proud of L.A. Animal Services once again,” Brad Smulson said.
Eileen Smulson added that the shelters have had inconsistent hours since the start of the pandemic, further reducing the opportunities for people to adopt or foster animals, and she and her husband called on the department to resume normal operating hours.
Scheduling appointments with the department has become so difficult that Smulson resorted to adopting a dog from Mexico instead of from one of the city’s shelters, she said.
Though Koretz’s report did not advocate for changing shelter hours, it recommended that the city relax its COVID-19 quarantine protocols, ending the current requirement for city employees to have a 10-day quarantine following an exposure, and instead requiring a quarantine of five days and a negative test.
Perhaps the most substantive motion calls for the city to transfer $3 million in emergency funds from the Reserve Fund to this year’s L.A. Animal Services budget to cover the cost of enhancing the spay and neutering program, increase funding for the Citywide Cat Program and enhance the budget for food, operational needs and animal enrichment programs.
Koretz introduced another motion to allocate funding for the department, calling for $100,000 to be transferred from the General City Purposes Fund into the Animal Welfare Trust Fund. The motion stems from a question posed by a critic of the department, who asked why the trust fund isn’t being used to hire more staff to supplement the dog walking program.
“Trust fund monies can be used to contract with consultants or contractors to handle various specific tasks that department staff is unable to address at a given time. Thus, the Animal Welfare Trust Fund can be used to bring in consulting firms, nonprofits and/or individual experts to address various departmental needs,” the report stated.
Many of Koretz’s motions seek to review and restructure the department’s operations, including one calling for a review of the hiring qualifications and training for animal care technicians. ACT’s are charged with keeping the kennels clean, but there are so many dogs that this becomes a nearly impossible task, according to the report.
The councilman also introduced motions for the department to report back to City Council in 30 days with plans to ensure all dogs are regularly exercised and properly attended to, and to ensure the best possible treatment of cats, rabbits and all other small animals during their stays at city animal shelters.
With a dwindling number of staff at the shelters, recruiting more technicians is sometimes made harder by an unfriendly atmosphere among employees, according to the report.
“Complainants who have come to the department via the Targeted Local Hire program noted that required training is made inconvenient for them and that existing staff sometimes make derogatory remarks and [are] not welcoming,” the report stated.
With these complaints in mind, Koretz also introduced a motion that the department report back to City Council in 30 days on its program to incorporate Targeted Local Hire trainees into the shelter operations, “including training and mentoring, and other procedures to give them the best chance of succeeding in their work for the department, and ways the program could be improved.” Another motion instructs L.A. Animal Services to report back to City Council within 30 days with a plan to ensure a better performing Joint Labor-Management Committee.
This motion also echoes a complaint from the report, which cites an L.A. Animal Services staff member who said that the JLMC would improve problem solving and communication at the shelters if it convened more frequently.
But the Smulsons also urged better discourse between the department and the public.
“We need better communication so we can get more animals adopted,” Brad Smulson said.











1 Comment
Paul Koretz is running for Controller. Where has he been over the past years while rescues have been bailing with a spoon trying to save animals? Where is the spay/neuter and licensing enforcement? Where is the crackdown on backyard breeders????? The answer to the overpopulation is ENFORCE the laws that are in place to stem the flow of animals IN to the shelters. This is not brain surgery, but, like all the other problems that have gotten out of control the current council has no problem solving skills of any kind. They only talk the talk when they are up for re-election or running for another of the musical chairs they wish to occupy in order to avoid getting a real job.