
According to a 1939 map, much of the city was graded “in decline,” making it difficult for homeowners to receive loans and mortgages. (photo courtesy of the city of West Hollywood)
West Hollywood is taking the first steps toward the creation of a reparations program to give restitution to residents who have historically been negatively affected by discriminatory policies.
The City Council on Monday approved a motion to start a request for proposals process for a historical context study that would evaluate the city’s policies and the potential establishment of a community reparations program.
Prior to 1984, West Hollywood was an unincorporated section of Los Angeles County. According to a staff report, many portions of the county had policies and laws in place that were designed to uphold discriminatory practices to segregate Black residents and other residents of color and to reinforce racial and class bias in home ownership.
Council members hope the study will help guide a framework for a reparations program as well as future decisions to improve city home ownership opportunities.
“Whatever we do will not adequately address compounded generations of racism and discrimination and exclusion, but hopefully we can do something meaningful that creates inclusion, creates more opportunity, attempts at equity, and educates all of us,” Councilwoman Lindsey Horvath said.
One of the most documented forms of discrimination in the 1930s was a policy of redlining in which the Home Owners Loan Corp., under the Federal Housing Administration, created a grading system to assess the desirability of residential communities. Areas labeled green were the most desired, while areas labeled red were considered “hazardous.”
Key factors that influenced the grades were race and class, and communities that had a large Black, Native American or Mexican American population typically received lower grades, according to the staff report.
Areas that were redlined were often denied mortgages and loans regardless of a resident’s qualifications, making property ownership more difficult. According to a 1939 HOLC map, most of what would eventually become West Hollywood is colored yellow, meaning “in decline.”
Additionally, restrictive deeds on real estate contracts in certain areas stipulated that the sale of property to non-white individuals was prohibited, which Councilman John D’Amico said can still be seen on the city’s deed records today.
“The deed restriction on our house says if you’re brown or Black you have to leave the city,” he said. “You cannot spend the night. You cannot live in that place. It’s horrible.”
Many experts argue that much of the wealth inequality that exists in the U.S. is driven by inequality in the real estate market and housing policies through the generations that have kept individuals from generating equity and building wealth, according to the staff report.
The reparations study would examine the historical context of racial segregation and discriminatory policies in the city to guide a potential reparations program. Future reparations could take the form of financial compensation, new land use policies and home ownership loans, which resident Jordan David said is necessary to effectively address the issue.
“We need to look at reparations holistically,” David said. “No amount of money can cover the systemic damage. Reparations must include aspects of housing, labor, education, access to credit and reversing criminalization.”
About $70,000 to $100,000 from the city’s general fund budget would be set aside for the study, and although Mayor Lauren Meister was in favor of enacting new policies, she said there was a way to make change without paying for a study while the city is experiencing a budget deficit.
She suggested evaluating the city’s land use policies to be more inclusive, granting no- or low-cost loans to Black residents to help achieve home ownership and developing a program to encourage minority-owned business.
“I really want to be thoughtful about this, and while I understand and appreciate the intentions of this report, I think that there’s a better way and a more fiscally responsible way to get where we want to go,” Meister said.
Meister, who also serves on the Southern California Association of Governments, said the organization has done “extensive research” that shows reparations are most effectively handled by federal governments. Resident Keith Kaplan agreed, stating the city should not fund the study.
He said that reparations should be left to the federal government and the motion was a way for council members to “say they were first” in establishing such a program.
“They’re using our city has a testing ground for these new ordinances with no consideration for our businesses,” Kaplan said. “They want to be first and enact their vision for establishing their political legacies whether or not it hurts their constituencies.”
Similar programs have been enacted throughout the U.S., including a $10 million program in Evanston, Illinois, and a $2.1 million program in Asheville, North Carolina.
The H.R. 40 bill, awaiting a vote from the House of Representatives, would establish a federal commission to study the legacy of slavery in the U.S. and develop proposals for redress, including reparations.
D’Amico said that the city has been supportive of H.R. 40 since its introduction in 2014, and it can now prioritize funding to support similar actions at a local level.
“We’re going to spend money on a pet memorial. We spend $2 million on Pride. We can find a way to do this – of course we can and of course we need to,” he said.
The motion was approved unanimously. City staff will provide a timeline at the council’s Jan. 18 meeting.












0 Comment