Metro’s Crenshaw Northern Extension project – included in Measure M, a half-cent sales tax increase which was approved by Los Angeles County voters in November 2016 – is supposed to break ground in 2041 and be operational by 2047.
However, according to a recent update during West Hollywood City Council on April 20, Metro could potentially start construction by 2026 with the appropriate funding. The northern extension would connect the Crenshaw/LAX Line, which runs between the Metro Green and Expo lines, with the Red/Purple lines using light rail through the city of West Hollywood.
“We believe that because of the work the city [of West Hollywood], Metro and other stakeholders have undertaken over the last five years, and will continue to undertake, there is a path forward where the project could begin construction approximately 15 years early,” said John Leonard, West Hollywood community and legislative affairs manager, who is working toward accelerating the Crenshaw Northern Extension.
Previously, the city of West Hollywood and Metro conducted community outreach and worked on various studies for the project, such as West Hollywood’s Funding and Project Delivery Strategy Study and Metro’s Advanced Alternatives Screening Study last year, according to the staff report.
Metro’s Crenshaw Northern Extension project is estimated to cost $6.4 billion, and the city of West Hollywood is expected to contribute up to 25% of capital costs within the City of West Hollywood, as more than half of the project would run through the city of Los Angeles, to fast-track the project.
In 2018, the city of West Hollywood conducted a survey that identified four funding sources.
Measures R and M would return local funds of approximately $48 million, a potential local sales tax increase between 0.5% and 0.75% could return $447 million, potential advertising around future stations could generate up to $65 million for the city, and, lastly, a potential Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District within a half-mile of the rail line within West Hollywood could raise $573 million for the project over a period of 45 years.
“An EIFD does not create any new taxes, nor does it raise taxes. It instead dedicates a portion of future revenue growth to an infrastructure project,” Leonard said. “EIFD’s can be effective because rail projects tend to increase property values in an area, and EIFD would dedicate a portion of that new revenue as property values increase to the rail project financing.”
Alone, the city of West Hollywood could contribute $1.1 billion, but as of now, no specific funding from West Hollywood has been approved for the project.
Councilman John Heilman said the project is still in the preliminary phase and community outreach is a high priority before decisions for funding are made.
“We would have to have a lot of conversations and a lot of meetings,” Heilman said. “This type of funding (EIFDs) is something that not a lot of people understand.”
Leonard added West Hollywood has a long history of prudent fiscal management, and it would only consider adopting an EIFD if West Hollywood were able to continue to provide the same level of services to residents and businesses, while also contributing to the construction of the rail line.
An EIFD can also serve as a tool to develop policies, such as anti-displacement policies to protect existing businesses and residents.
Recently, the county and city of L.A. joined a working group for the Crenshaw Northern Extension, which would potentially change an EIFD, as the size of it will increase along with the amount of potential revenue. The working group will also seek alternative methods of funding at the state and federal levels, and finalize a finance plan in the future.
“The project is critical not only to West Hollywood, but for the entire region,” Mayor Pro Tempore Lindsey Horvath said. “We know that it will reach critical destinations such as Cedars-Sinai, Beverly Grove, Inglewood and Crenshaw communities.”
Leonard said some of the criteria Metro considers for advancing projects include funding from a local jurisdiction, expedited local approvals and interagency coordination. He outlined recent developments of a Los Angeles City Council motion supporting the acceleration of the project, interagency coordination between Metro, the Los Angeles County, and the cities of Los Angeles and West Hollywood, and results of a transportation survey that was conducted by West Hollywood in January and February.
He added Metro is ready to start the environmental impact review and begin more detailed discussions with the cities of West Hollywood and L.A., and Los Angeles County, about how the project would be funded.
“These are both very important steps and mean that the project could begin construction once the environmental review is complete, and a plan of finance is agreed upon by all agencies,” Leonard said.
Metro obtained a contract for a possible consultant agency, which would conduct the environmental review, but it is tentatively scheduled for the Metro board meeting on May 28. A decision may be delayed by a month or two as Metro reassesses its budget as a result of the impact of the coronavirus pandemic.
But, if Metro decides to move forward with the consultant agency, the environmental review will occur in three phases. The first phase is to prepare a study that details the various environmental impacts the project will have and include Metro’s strategy to mitigate them under the California Environmental Quality Act, Leonard said.
The first phase takes approximately 24 months or more and will provide key information for the selection of an alignment, or route, for the Crenshaw Northern Extension. In 2018, Metro conducted a screening survey that identified five possible alignments: La Brea, Fairfax and three options for a San Vicente route.
Leonard said Metro is considering the alignments at La Brea, Fairfax, and a hybrid San Vicente/Fairfax route over other options. Any construction in the city of West Hollywood will most likely occur underground for the project.
The next phases can occur at the same time and include beginning the more detailed engineering work on the project and preparing a similar study of environmental impacts under federal guidelines known as the National Environmental Policy Act.
On May 28, when Metro’s board of directors meet, it will decide whether to approve the consultant and either choose to arrange a contract for the full scope of work or only for the first phase, with contracts for the secondary phases coming later, Leonard said.
Partner agencies will also be able to review and comment on all of the environmental documents.
Ultimately, the city of West Hollywood will continue to advocate for acceleration of the Crenshaw Northern Extension.
“This is a great opportunity to build a subway to serve West Hollywood,” Heilman said. “The report overwhelmingly shows West Hollywood wants transportation.”
The city conducted a Transportation Issues Survey of approximately 560 residents which showed that residents would like to see the project move forward. However, there has to be more communication, Horvath said, as the survey showed only 48% of respondents were aware of the project.
“This was a request of the council to go back to the community and have this discussion,” Horvath said. “Clearly, our numbers show that we need to continue having these conversations. The more we talk about it, the more we inform people.”
Approximately 60% of survey participants said they wanted rail in West Hollywood built underground, even if it increases the cost of the project, versus 25% who want rail built above ground, which would decrease costs. Approximately 15% of participants were unsure.
“The study reaffirms what we already knew, that people want this,” Horvath said. “We believe extension is critical, it makes financial sense and the sooner we get started … we can get to construction right away.”












0 Comment