The Beverly Hills City Council voted 3-2 on Dec. 5 to implement a five-year plan for water rate increases amid strong opposition from the city’s West Hollywood customers.
Beverly Hills provides water to the western portion of West Hollywood, where residents’ water bills have long included a 25 percent surcharge. Speaking before the council at Beverly Hills City Hall, West Hollywood Councilwoman Lauren Meister said there is “no direct documentation” to justify the surcharge.
Beverly Hills Mayor Lili Bosse cast one of the dissenting votes, saying it was “unacceptable” that West Hollywood officials did not receive information they had requested regarding the surcharge until the day before the Beverly Hills City Council originally planned to vote on the rate increases last month. After the meeting ran longer than anticipated, the council agreed to postpone the public hearing and vote to Dec. 5.

West Hollywood Councilwoman Lauren Meister questioned Beverly Hills council members about a 25 percent surcharge levied to West Hollywood residents who get their water from Beverly Hills. (photo courtesy of the city of Beverly Hills)
“The way we are addressing our neighbor is not appropriate,” Bosse said.
A city of Beverly Hills cost allocation study states that a “share of certain costs that have historically been funded from the general fund” are issued to West Hollywood’s Beverly Hills customers. Three cost allocation areas the study addresses are public safety, governmental facilities and right-of-way maintenance.
“Each of these areas represents a service provided for the benefit of the enterprise by the general fund and for which the enterprise should provide reimbursement,” the report reads.
The general fund covers reimbursements from the water enterprise only for ratepayers in Beverly Hills, according to the report. Without the 25 percent surcharge, “Beverly Hills residents would be subsidizing outside city customers,” Shana Epstein, Beverly Hills director of Public Works, has said.
Epstein said in a previous interview that the city “[has not] done a good job explaining all that.” Bosse also said she wanted better outreach to the city’s water customers about the water quality, reliability and infrastructure projects that the increased rates will support.
Under the proposed increase, and based on average water usage, a single-family residential customer will pay an additional $5.50 to $6.50 on each bimonthly bill over the next five years, according to the Beverly Hills Public Works Department. The increase would amount to a $29.52 increase on each bimonthly bill at the end of the five-year period. The rates are set to take effect on Jan. 1 each year from 2018 to 2022. Stormwater, solid waste and wastewater rates will not increase, but they might be subject to future increases.
West Hollywood residents sent 88 letters of protest to the rate increases prior to the vote, compared to seven from Beverly Hills residents.
Councilman John Mirisch, who cast the other dissenting vote, said the council has a tendency to “spend like drunken sailors” and then “act like puritan bankers.”
“We waste money, we spend money, we give money away, and sometimes like it’s going out of style,” Mirisch said, mentioning funding the council recently allocated for holiday decorations.
He implied a double standard between the proliferation of unfunded pension liabilities – which the council discussed at its study session on Tuesday afternoon, and has been a statewide issue – while meticulously raising water rates to match rising costs.
“When it comes to our residents, we are not shy to stick it to them, and we are not shy to stick it to West Hollywood residents,” the councilman said.
A few residents from West Hollywood addressed the council during public comment.
“It is almost like the surcharge is a subsidy on the Beverly Hills lawn,” said Patrick Shandrick, of the West Hollywood West Residents Association.
West Hollywood West’s secretary, Kimberly Winick, said she doesn’t think the surcharge is appropriate.
“This certainly feels like taxation without representation,” she said.
Councilman Robert Wunderlich said there is a “sound conceptual basis” to levy the surcharge on Beverly Hills’ West Hollywood customers, but figuring out a dollar amount instead of a percent surcharge could be a more palatable arrangement.
Vice Mayor Julian Gold said that Beverly Hills should have a “robust conversation” with West Hollywood about the surcharge.
“It may well be there are creative solutions that would obviate the need for this surcharge,” he said.












0 Comment