The city of West Hollywood tightened its ordinance prohibiting the sale of fur on Aug. 17 to include a provision that disallows the display of fur clothing items with intention to sell them online or at another location.

Mayfair House now carries UggPure shoes, which are made from shorn wool and do not use the animal’s actual skin to make the footwear. (photo courtesy of Mayfair House)
“This fix is to make it clear that it isn’t just the question of selling fur, the ban is also addressing having the product offered for sale in the store,” West Hollywood City Attorney Michael Jenkins said. “We want the ordinance to be completely clear about that, as that was the intention of it all along.”
Alternately, the city council voted to allow the sale of fur that has been procured by a hunter who has a state trapping license. A California state law is in place that allows the sale of fur with a trappers license, which conflicted with West Hollywood’s 2013 decision to ban all sales. While Jenkins and his supporters do not completely agree with the issue of allowing those with trappers licenses to sell fur, he says it is a minor provision to the ordinance.
“Really, how many of those are we going to get?” Jenkins said. “The bulk of fur that is turned into clothing comes from fur farms, not trapping.”
Keith Kaplan, chairman of the West Hollywood Chamber of Commerce, said the amendment allowing the sale of certain types of fur from hunters with trapping licenses only takes the city one step further away from being fur-free.
“It will allow West Hollywood shops to carry a fairly wide array of types of fur in their stores, and has really made the ordinance very complex,” Kaplan said. “It seems that they have just randomly and arbitrarily banned fur at stores, while still not addressing some of the concerns that the businesses have.”
The first official fur ban went into effect on Sept. 21, 2013 and was the first of its kind in the United States. City officials hope that the clarification to the ordinance prohibiting both the sale of fur and the displaying of fur with intent to sell sets a pattern for the rest of the country.
“For the first time the council voted unanimously to uphold and strengthen the fur ban, and it’s clear that this is an ordinance that the entire city council wants in place,” said John D’Amico, who initially introduced the ordinance in 2013.
According to Jenkins, the ban on selling fur in the city is “exclusively a question of animal welfare.”
Mayfair House, a boutique department store in West Hollywood, was issued a citation for displaying fur products – Ugg boots – but was not actually caught selling them. Following the citation, the store challenged the ban in federal court and again in state court. The two issues discussed at the city council meeting Monday were largely brought to light on account of a request for clarification from the state court regarding the current case between Mayfair House and the city of West Hollywood.
Liz Solomon, spokesperson for Mayfair House, said the amended provisions have only opened the floodgates for the sale of different types of fur in West Hollywood.
“The new ordinance completely validates the sale of fur except shearling or cow,” Solomon said. “What they have said with this is that it’s OK to trap a fox and kill it and offer its skin for sale, but it’s not OK to use the fur of a lamb that is otherwise killed for meat.”
Additionally, Kaplan argues that the ordinance hurts West Hollywood in a more general way, as the city invested in attracting many high-end fashion retailers and brands in the early 2000s as part of a plan to establish it as a fashion destination. By changing the rules and enforcing a limited ban, he said, it may make retailers think twice before renewing or signing their leases.
“For most of the brands that open a storefront in Los Angeles, in addition to retail, it is also for the purpose of marketing and public relations. This is where they expose their entire lines to stylists, which often include fur. Prohibiting any kind of display of fur, then, could be problematic,” Kaplan said.
However, D’Amico argues that the ban has actually helped the businesses in West Hollywood and is in the best interest of the city.
“The affect on the business district seems to be very small. We did a study in 2012 on the potential effect of the ban, which showed very little change to the city’s bottom line and the retailer’s bottom line, and it’s proven to be true,” D’Amico said. “The design district’s vacancies in the retail stores are actually lower than ever.”
Lindsay Larris, regional director for Los Angeles Animal Legal Defense Fund, stated that she believes people are visiting West Hollywood specifically in support of its decision to ban fur products.
“We think that West Hollywood has always been great about passing ordinances that have been on the forefront of times,” Larris said. “There are many more vegan leather products than ever, and we want to let people know that you don’t need to use fur or animal products to be fashionable. This city is such a center for fashion, so if we can do it here, it will help motivate other cities.”
Solomon said that she actually applauds the animal rights activists’ efforts to create ethical clothing, but feels that Mayfair House has been unfairly targeted for their sale of Ugg products.
“We feel like this has been a huge missed opportunity for the activists and the city. When it was first presented, we were fully on board with educating the community on dealing with reputable dealers when buying their fur from legitimate sources, like Ugg,” Solomon said. “Now I feel like the amendment allowing the sale of fur from someone with a trapping license has created the exact issue that they were trying so hard to fight.”
Mayfair House has removed all fur Uggs from their stores and is proceeding with a lawsuit against the city in state court. Their federal case against West Hollywood was dismissed last year. Armed with the amended ordinance to the two issues that the state judge had pointed out, Jenkins hopes to get Mayfair’s case in state court dismissed as well.












0 Comment