An independent hearing examiner has dismissed a citation levied against fashion retailer Mayfair House for violating the West Hollywood Fur Ban Ordinance by displaying a fur product and offering to sell fur items.
Mayfair House is currently in the midst of challenging the ban in Los Angeles Superior Court, and according to court information, hearings related to the case are expected to be held in May.
“We feel wonderful that someone looked at it logically and realized it should be thrown out,” Mayfair House spokeswoman Liz Solomon said. “That whole display issue is very ambiguous.”
According to a press release, a code compliance officer issued Mayfair House a citation in April after observing UGG boots in a display case at the store. The hearing officer dismissed the citation earlier this month.
Since the ban went into effect in September 2013, Mayfair House representatives have argued that the ban has hamstringed the business, which sells UGG boots and Canada Goose jackets. They also feel that the ordinance is unfair, as it does not impact the sale of home furnishings and furniture.
“We just want it to go away. It should go away,” Solomon said, adding that she wished the city would have used the ordinance as an opportunity to make residents and businesses more aware of humane brands that source their products. “I just want it to be amicably resolved in the best interest of all concerned.”
Originally, Mayfair House filed its lawsuit in federal court, and last May, it was dismissed without prejudice.
Solomon said it is difficult to tell if the city will alter the ordinance to include displaying fur products and offering to sell them. Mayor John D’Amico and the city attorney, Michael Jenkins, said the city does not plan to expand the ordinance.
“For now, we’re just going to continue to enforce the ordinance and, I guess, wait to see when Mayfair House becomes more humane. Hopefully they will,” D’Amico said.
He said he does not believe the city was too extreme in banning the sale of products like UGG boots, which are fairly common fashion items.
“No, not at all,” D’Amico said. “I think one retailer is being propped up by a sinister fur organization, and that’s how it works in America. You get to file a lawsuit.”
He said Mayfair House is the one retailer in a city with thousands that has opted to challenge the ban. D’Amico said the number of fashion retailers impacted by the ban was “very low.”
According to information provided by D’Amico’s office, almost 30 fashion retailers have moved into West Hollywood since the ban was proposed. Dash Boutique and Tommy Hilfiger are among them.
“It’s a marketplace, and we’re in the center of it,” D’Amico said. “And people want to be in the center of it.”
He said the fur ban has resulted in good press and praise for the city of West Hollywood since it was proposed.
According to the lawsuit, first-time offenders of the ordinance can be subjected to an $800 administrative penalty plus a fee of $50. After a citation is issued, the offender has 21 days to file a written request for a hearing to dispute the citation. The city of West Hollywood contracts with Judy Sherman, who handles all administrative hearings in the city. Had Mayfair House lost, representatives could have appealed the decision to the superior court.











0 Comment